Council approves composting contract despite Texas Disposal Systems objections
City Council approved a contract Thursday to dramatically expand the city’s curbside organics collection and composting program.
The new contract builds upon the pilot program that has been in place for nearly four years. Under that program, Organics By Gosh, a local composting firm run by a husband-and-wife duo, processed organic waste collected from the curbs in front of 14,300 homes at no cost to the city. It would then process the waste and sell it for profit.
Under the new contract, the same company will gradually expand its service to roughly 200,000 homes by the end of the three-year contract, for which the city is paying $1.51 million.
The contract was approved unanimously, but not until after a lengthy debate over whether Council should delay approval to get additional feedback from a working group that was formed in April to evaluate how waste contracts are awarded.
Leading the charge for a postponement was Michael Whellan, an attorney representing Texas Disposal Systems, who argued that Organics By Gosh had yet to answer a number of important questions about its plans for processing the massive amounts of waste it would now be responsible for.
Texas Disposal Systems did not bid on the contract itself. The company has refused to enter bids that would require it to submit to the city’s anti-lobbying ordinance, which a company official told the Austin Monitor Thursday it is working to change. It has, however, opposed other companies’ bids on waste contracts.
Whellan began by ridiculing Organics By Gosh’s current 2.79-acre processing site in eastern Travis County as far too small to accommodate all of the anticipated waste, likening it to “hosting ACL in a pocket park.” Plus, he noted, part of the site is located within a 100-year floodplain, in violation of a Travis County ordinance.
Whellan then noted that the company has acquired a second, much larger site in Bastrop County and wondered aloud whether the company was going to be charging the city extra to haul the waste a longer distance. Finally, he noted that Organics By Gosh had said it was pursuing a third site but would not disclose its location.
The contract, said Whellan, presented “numerous unanswered questions.”
Whellan’s testimony prompted a vociferous rebuke from Donna Gosh, one of the company’s namesakes, who accused Texas Disposal Systems of “sowing fear and spreading incomplete information” and repeatedly dismissed the potential competitor’s objections as “nonsense.”
The Travis County ordinance prohibiting composting in floodplains is a national anomaly, she said, adding that the county has granted her business an exemption. Nor, she said, did the company plan to charge the city more for the cost of hauling waste to the new site in Bastrop.
Later, Phil Gosh, the other half of company ownership, explained that he wasn’t quite ready to disclose the location of a new composting site that the company is in the process of acquiring north of Austin.
“This waste industry is kind of ruthless,” he said. “Competition has been known to buy property right next to you and then make things difficult for you in terms of permitting.”
While Council members appeared satisfied with the Gosh’s explanations, there was some initial division about whether they should authorize city staff to negotiate and execute the contract right away.
Mayor Steve Adler said he had hoped that an expected report from the working group would inform his decision on the contract. Council Member Leslie Pool thus offered an amendment to authorize staff to negotiate the contract but come back to Council in August to receive approval before executing it.
After debate among Council members – and a plea from Donna Gosh to “end this nonsense” – Council instead approved a substitute amendment by Council Member Jimmy Flannigan that gave staff the OK to negotiate and execute the three-year contract. However, in contrast to what was proposed by staff, the contract cannot be automatically renewed for three subsequent years without Council approval.
Ultimately, Adler was the only one who voted against Flannigan’s amendment. Council Member Ann Kitchen abstained.
Outside Council chambers after the vote, Adam Gregory, son of Texas Disposal Systems founder Bob Gregory, said that he was disappointed that Council voted “without knowing a lot of facts behind it.”
“I think it would have been more appropriate to finish the policy discussion that we’ve been having and adopt changes to the purchasing process before we approve a contract like this,” he said.
Donna Gosh kept it simple when asked for comment on the big win for her company.
“Go God!” she said. “This was all God’s doing.”
This story has been corrected. We originally reported that Organics by Josh collected organic waste during the pilot program when, in fact, the company processed waste collected by the city.
The Austin Monitor’s work is made possible by donations from the community. Though our reporting covers donors from time to time, we are careful to keep business and editorial efforts separate while maintaining transparency. A complete list of donors is available here, and our code of ethics is explained here.
Do you like this story?
There are so many important stories we don't get to write. As a nonprofit journalism source, every contributed dollar helps us provide you more coverage. Do your part by joining our subscribers in supporting our reporters' work.
Key Players & Topics In This Article
Austin City Council: The Austin City Council is the body with legislative purview over the City of Austin. It offers policy direction, while the office of the City Manager implements administrative actions based on those policies. Until 2012, the body contained seven members, including the city's Mayor, all elected at-large. In 2012, City of Austin residents voted to change that system and now 10 members of the Council are elected based on geographic districts. The Mayor continues to be elected at-large.
Austin Resource Recovery: Formerly Solid Waste Services. The department in charge of handling solid waste disposal, recycling, and--in what is still a pilot program--curb-side composting for the City of Austin.
Texas Disposal Systems (TDS): An Austin-San Antonio landfill, recycling and composting system.